|
Earnings Problems? Not in Health Care
With the nation’s attention directed
toward the impending war and nerves rattled by threatened terrorist
attacks in our major metropolitan areas, it is difficult to focus on
earnings results for fourth quarter 2002, but focus we must. Now that the
Internet bubble is a thing of the past, when earnings did not appear to
matter, investors are paying attention to earnings trends, and health care
has been surprisingly resilient. Just as the health care industry led the
merger and acquisition market in 2002, we would not be surprised to see
health care revenue and profit growth lead all sectors of the economy for
last year as well.
Although all companies
have not reported fourth quarter and year-end results yet, our sampling of
about 50 companies across all major segments has yielded some impressive
results. However, we excluded companies (such as small biotechnology
firms) that have no revenues. In addition, several of the companies that
posted losses were expected to do so, but saw a reduction in the loss
compared to the previous year’s fourth quarter loss. Compared with the
fourth quarter in 2001, nearly 70% of the companies surveyed had
double-digit revenue growth in the 2002 fourth quarter, and more than
one-third of those were over 20%.
When looking at earnings
per share (excluding one-time charges), a similar pattern emerges, with
more than 65% of the companies posting double-digit growth and the
majority of those above 20%. This is one of the reasons why so many people
are bullish on the health care sector even as the Dow drops below 8000
again. Even many of the large pharmaceutical companies, which as a sector
is supposed to be faltering as blockbuster drugs come off patent and
generics cut into profits, fared reasonably well, the notable exception
being Merck (NYSE: MCK), which had flat earnings.
While investors
concentrated on the problems of the pharmaceutical industry in 2002,
managed care companies may well be the focus of investor attention, as
well as the government’s, in 2003 as the health care economy grapples
with out-of-control costs. So far, all of the major health care insurers
have been reporting solid earnings growth, except Oxford Health Plans
(NYSE: OHP), which reported a 16% decline in net earnings on an 18% rise
in revenues in the fourth quarter. Investors may have questioned some of
the components of its latest earnings report, driving its share price to a
52-week low of $27.89 on February 12.
The largest health
insurer, UnitedHealth Group (NYSE: UNH), reported a 58% surge in
earnings per share on an 11% increase in revenues in the fourth quarter.
The earnings beat Wall Street’s estimates by $0.04 per share, and the
company, with more than 17 million enrollees, expects to increase premiums
by 13% while medical costs are estimated to rise by 11% to 12%. Despite
this news, UNH’s shares have dropped to their lowest level since early
December.
The second largest health
insurer, Aetna (NYSE: AET), posted a healthy fourth quarter profit
compared with a loss in the year-ago quarter, on a revenue decline of 22%.
The revenue decline was mostly the result of shedding several unprofitable
accounts, and sequential quarterly revenues are not expected to turn
upwards until mid-2003. Most importantly, AET’s commercial HMO medical
loss ratio (MLR) dropped to 80.4% in the fourth quarter, compared with
81.4% in the third quarter and 89.7% in the fourth quarter of 2001. With
15% premium increases in 2003 and medical costs expected to rise by 12% to
13% at the company, earnings may rise by 15% this year. Management has
estimated 2003 earnings per share to be in the range of $3.30 to $3.40,
significantly higher than original analyst estimates of $3.08 per share. A
$275 million reduction in SG&A in 2003 will also contribute to the
higher earnings. The stock price has done little since the earnings
results were released, and with a 12x PE ratio based on 2003 earnings,
investors may not be entirely convinced, or else the shorts are keeping a
lid on any price increase.
After being extremely
pessimistic last October, with two cuts in its earnings forecast, Cigna
(NYSE: CI) beat revised estimates for the fourth quarter by seven cents,
causing the company’s share price to jump by 12% in early February. But
one-half of that increase was lost in the following days, and the stock,
at $41.75 per share, is a far cry from its 52-week high of $111 per share.
Just like Aetna, CI has shed unprofitable accounts and is slashing costs,
including the elimination of up to 3,900 jobs. Unlike most of the other
insurers, however, CI’s commercial HMO MLR in the fourth quarter
increased to 86.4% from 85.5% a year ago. The company will have to
increase premiums by larger percentages than the rest of the market and
will lose some business in 2003 as a result.
Two of the largest
operators of Blue Cross and Blue Shield plans, WellPoint Health
Networks (NYSE: WLP) and Anthem (NYSE: ATH), posted earnings
per share gains of 42% and 40%, respectively, in the fourth quarter. But
these results did nothing for their shares. In the case of Anthem, which
raised its earnings per share forecast for 2003 by $0.10 per share, its
share price tumbled to a new 52-week low of $53.00 per share. Revenues are
expected to be up 23% this year, and the integration of its acquisition of
Trigon Healthcare is on track with expected savings of $50 million
in 2003 alone. Management may be asking what else it can do to satisfy
investors.
Perhaps the problem has
something to do with "Medicare reform," as briefly outlined in
the recent State of the Union address, which may involve a private-sector
drug benefits plan. Unfortunately, it’s beginning to sound like the
existing Medicare+Choice plans, which have not been popular, or
profitable, with insurers. The other potential problem is whether managed
care plans will get the math right if they have to redesign benefit plans
to implement benefit buydowns by large corporate customers.
Meanwhile, hospital costs
account for almost 50% of total medical costs incurred by HMOs, and other
than some fallout from Tenet Healthcare’s (NYSE: THC) Medicare
problems, hospitals are quite happy with increasing rates. As we have said
before, something has got to change, and with change comes miscalculation,
which often results in volatile earnings. It may be looking good for
managed care companies today, but investors apparently are not willing to
buy into the long term.
The earnings front has
not been all good news, and often that has been related to 2003 forecasts.
An example of this is Accredo Health (NASDAQ: ACDO), which provides
pharmacy services to patients with chronic diseases. Earnings for the
company’s second quarter ended December 31, 2002 doubled on a 127% jump
in revenues from an acquisition, but because of slower sales for some of
its products, revenues for the year ending June 30, 2003 will be about 3%
below previous forecasts, and earnings per share for fiscal 2003 and 2004
will be slightly below estimates. This news sent the share price down more
than 25%, ultimately hitting a 52-week low of $24.17.
Last March, MedSource
Technologies (NASDAQ: MEDT), a medical device manufacturer, went
public at $12.00 per share, hit a high of $15.11 within a few weeks, and
then slowly descended over several months to about $6.00 per share. But
when MEDT announced in late January a cut in its 2003 profit forecast
because of lower sales, the stock plunged by 50% and recently hit a new
low of $2.38 per share. No wonder there’s no IPO market.
If you think things are
bad, it is always worse somewhere else. IntraBiotics Pharmaceuticals (NASDAQ:
IBPI), which is engaged in the development of novel antibiotics but which
has no revenues, reported a net loss of $10.3 million in the fourth
quarter. It also announced that the number of employees had declined from
37 to 11 during the quarter, but that the number had dropped to just five
by January. The good news? It has $13.3 million of cash ($0.35 per share)
and perhaps a viable product for the prevention of ventilator-associated
pneumonia. The bad news? The current share price is just $0.18, down 96%
from last April.
|