|
October 2008
issue
The Collapse Of Wall Street--
And What It Means For Seniors Housing And Care
As credit dries up and Wall Street as we know it heads for a dramatic
change, what will be the impact on seniors housing and care?
...
The GPT Group And Benchmark--
Now Is Not The Time To Sell A Strategic Portfolio
With troubles back in Australia and a soft occupancy market in the U.S., The
GPT Group is thinking about selling its recently acquired stake in Benchmark
Assisted Living. So what ever happened to patient, long-term investing?
...
Assisted Living Market
Skilled Healthcare Group expanded its already strong presence in Kansas with
the acquisition of a small portfolio.
...
Retirement Housing Deals
Five Star and Senior Housing Properties Trust are buying eight communities
in Indiana.
...
Skilled Nursing Sales
Sales are few in number and low in price, but
they are getting done.
...
Is Transparency Enough?
The seniors housing industry has been criticized for not being transparent
enough to be easily understood.
...
Sign
up for a trial subscription and get the current issue!
Read more about
The
SeniorCare Investor.
Articles Archive
Steve's BLOG on Senior Care
Companies Mentioned in this issue:
October 2008
A
AEW Capital p2
Arcapita p4, p17
B
Benchmark Assisted Living p1
Bickford Senior Living Group p12
Brookdale Living Communities p17
Brookdale Senior Living p12
C
Cain Brothers p8
Capmark Finance p12
Care Investment Trust p12
Christopher Place Senior Communities p8
Contemporary Healthcare Capital p12
F
Fannie Mae p6, p18
Five Star Quality Care p6
FKP Property Group p1
Freddie Mac p18
G
Grandbridge Real Estate Capital p12
H
HCP Inc. p12
Health Care REIT p4, p17
L
Landmark Realty Capital p12
Liberty Healthcare p10
Long-Term Capital Management p1
M
Marcus & Millichap p6
O
Omega Healthcare Investors p17
P
Peak Medical p8
Provider Services, Inc. p10
R
Red Mortgage Capital p6
Retirement Management, Inc. p6
S
Senior Housing Properties Trust p6
Senior Living Investment Brokerage p6
Skilled Healthcare Group p5
Smith Barney p19
Stifel Nicolaus p17
Sun Healthcare Group p8
Sunrise Senior Living p1, p4, p17
Sunwest Management p6
T
The Bank of Indianapolis p6
The GPT Group p1
The Wharton School p14
U
UBS Investment Bank p17
|
The Collapse Of Wall Street--
And What It Means For Seniors Housing And Care
Email this
article to a friend
Email Editor
We have all read the headlines: "Wall Street Undone," "Wall Street Has
Changed Forever," "Bye-Bye Bonuses," "Credit Markets Seize Up." Bankers,
borrowers, investors and consumers are all scared, and while our
do-nothing Congressional leaders and their merry band of whiners insist on
playing the blame game (by the way, how does a state elect both Mitt
Romney and Barney Frank without noticing the irony?), everyone else
continues to suffer. The media has contributed to the hysteria as well. On
the night of September 29, every news show talked about how the collective
"we" lost $1.2 trillion in savings that day, but the next night did they
tell us how we made $750 billion in one day? Of course not.
Wall Street’s eulogy has been delivered several times in
the past 40 years, including the 1970s when fixed-rate commissions were
abolished, Black Monday in 1987 with the largest one-day percentage drop
in history and the Long-Term Capital Management bailout in the
1990s. While these events jolted the markets with the proverbial wake-up
call, what is happening today is much more pervasive and as such, the
impact will be longer lasting. In addition, in each of the past crises,
Wall Street bankers were not talking about the end of Wall Street as we
know it (the commission change may be the exception). That is not the case
today. Because of the immense size of the combined federal bailouts in
this crisis, there will be a price to pay, and everyone will pay it.
But what does change on Wall Street really mean? Other
than the obvious lower profits and smaller bonuses, risk-taking will
decline, competition will decrease, innovation will be hampered by what
will be a more intrusive government (protecting its investment) and, most
importantly for the seniors housing and care industry, the cost of capital
will rise regardless of what happens to interest rates, at least for a few
years. While not something that we want, there is a positive side to this
development, at least for those providers with buildings already open.
There may be fewer new entrants to the industry and new construction will
be scaled back, helping occupancy rates because the demand for the product
will certainly not decline. Operating income should rise when all of these
influences start to impact the market.
The name of the game right now is liquidity, and in this
market it currently does not exist. The number of large national banks is
now down to three, the large finance companies that have been major
players in seniors housing are trying to figure out where they can raise
capital and what their role will be in the new environment (and they all
want a significant role) and the CMBS market is shut down for now. The
tax-exempt bond market has seized up, not because there is a credit
problem with the issuers, but because the bond funds are seeing
withdrawals and letter-of-credit support is hard to find. The big question
is what will happen to the role of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac
in seniors housing next year? They are open for business (see Financing
News on page 12), but if the government decides their entire focus should
be to support the residential housing market, and "affordable housing" -
not realizing their importance to the multifamily and seniors housing
markets - then we will soon learn what a real liquidity crisis is like in
our sector.
So who wins in this environment? Obviously, anyone with
money, and right now we would put health care REITs at the top of that
short list. Many of these REITs that were instrumental in financing the
growth of the industry in the 1980s and 1990s have been diversifying away
from seniors housing and care, primarily away from the
reimbursement-dependant skilled nursing sector. With a combined $3 billion
to $5 billion of capital to invest, depending on how you want to measure
it, health care REITs are in a perfect position to capitalize on their
industry expertise and desire to invest. With the cost of everyone else’s
capital going up, combined with the demand for more equity from
traditional lenders, REITs will not be losing out on pricing at this time.
In fact, because the demand for capital remains high, they are in a
position to be quite selective regarding whom they will deal with, and our
suggestion would be that they become more creative in how they structure
their investments, including more short-term deals. Despite all the
progress that has been made in educating the capital markets in the past
10 years, it is almost as if we are back in the late 1980s to early 1990s
when health care REITs reigned supreme in the seniors housing finance
market. This won’t last forever, so they should capitalize on it while the
going is good.
Others that should benefit from the current environment
are mezzanine funds (that are still open and have money) because the
demand for their funds will only grow through next year. Any regional bank
with a strong balance sheet (and they do exist) is in a great position to
provide mortgage financing, and they are doing so on a regional basis with
small loans of $5 million to $20 million. When the dust settles, with the
number of large investment banking firms cut in half, we expect to see a
surge in boutique firms, not trading for their own account, but providing
capital raising and M&A advice, which is precisely what the big boys did
25 years ago. And in this market they will make their money the old
fashioned way, they will earn it (thank you, Smith Barney).
It is always important to remember that capital is a
commodity, it moves quickly and has no boundaries. As such it will always
go where the returns are the highest for the relative amount of risk.
Despite the gyrations in the seniors housing publicly traded equities over
the last few months, with much of that volatility based on fear,
uncertainty and a lack of knowledge of the facts, the seniors housing and
care industry not only remains a relatively safe investment vehicle, the
returns will be favorable for many years and should beat other "real
estate" oriented investments as well as other health care investments. The
impact on the industry from the crisis of confidence on Wall Street may be
severe in the short term, but it will also result in a more inward-looking
industry focusing on operations, staffing, quality of care innovations
and, perhaps, cooperation, and that will benefit everyone in the long
term. For now, however, the strongest credits will still have access to
capital, albeit at a higher price, while the weaker credits will either be
locked out of the market or the price will be too high. For everyone in
the industry there will be a renewed lender focus on track record, and it
better be a good one.
|
|
FREE TRIAL
TO THE
SENIORCARE
INVESTOR!
If you like this article, there’s lots more
waiting for you in The SeniorCare Investor. It’s the
bible of what's going on in senior care M&A today.
Sign up for two free months right now! There’s no
obligation, no writing “cancel” on a bill. Happy reading!
|
|
|
|
|
|